Answer with a salute - NYT Crossword Clue

Introduction

Today's clue, "Answer with a salute," is a classic example of a straightforward, context-based clue. It asks the solver to think of a phrase that is spoken while performing a specific action. This type of clue relies on common cultural knowledge, often gleaned from movies, television, and literature.

Clue Analysis

The clue can be broken down into two key parts:

1. "Answer": This points to a verbal response, likely one of affirmation or acknowledgement.
2. "with a salute": This provides the crucial context. We need a response that is specifically and strongly associated with the act of saluting.

The combination of these two parts leads us to a phrase used to show respect and obedience, typically in a formal, hierarchical setting like the armed forces.

Thinking Approaches

For a clue like this, a direct association approach is often the most effective:

1. Brainstorming: What words or phrases do you immediately associate with a salute? You might think of military settings. Common responses include "Aye, aye, captain!", "Sir, yes, sir!", or the more concise version of the latter.

2. Mental Imagery: Picture a scene from a military film. A general gives an order to a private. The private crisply salutes and says...? The phrase that comes to mind is almost certainly the answer.

3. Crossings: If you're stuck, getting a few crossing letters can quickly confirm the answer. For instance, seeing a 'Y' at the beginning or an 'R' at the end would be a huge giveaway.

This clue doesn't involve complex wordplay; it's a direct definition of a scenario, so it's best not to overthink it.

Background Context

The answer is a colloquial contraction of "Yes, sir." While heavily associated with military protocol across the English-speaking world, its usage extends to any situation where a subordinate wishes to show enthusiastic respect and compliance to a superior. It conveys a sense of discipline and eagerness that a simple "yes" might not.

In crossword puzzles, common spoken phrases like this are often condensed into a single word to fit the grid, which is a convention solvers quickly learn to recognize.

Conclusion

"Answer with a salute" is a great example of an accessible and satisfying clue. It taps into a shared cultural understanding, making the connection between the clue and the answer feel both natural and clever. It's a solid piece of cluing that rewards the solver for thinking about the real-world context of the phrase.

Hints

1. Hint 1: Think of a formal, affirmative response.
2. Hint 2: This phrase is often associated with the military or other hierarchical organizations.
3. Hint 3: It's a two-word phrase often written as one word in crosswords.
4. Hint 4: It's a respectful way to say 'yes' to a superior officer.