Pointer up high - NYT Crossword Clue

Introduction

Today's clue, "Pointer up high," is a fantastic example of how crossword constructors use simple, everyday words to create a clever puzzle. At first glance, the clue might evoke images of stars, fingers pointing to the sky, or even a tall dog breed. However, the solution lies in a more literal interpretation of a "pointer" that is physically located "up high."

Clue Analysis

The clue can be broken down into two key parts:

1. "Pointer": This is the core of the misdirection. Instead of a person or a tool for pointing, think of an indicator. What object's primary function is to point in a specific direction?
2. "Up high": This is the crucial qualifier. It tells us the location of this "pointer." We're not looking for something on the ground or in our hands; we're looking for something elevated, likely on a structure.

When we combine these ideas, we're searching for an object that indicates direction and is found in a high place, like on top of a building.

Thinking Approaches

When faced with a clue like this, a good strategy is to brainstorm associations for each part of the phrase.

• Word Association for "Pointer": arrow, indicator, sign, compass, finger, guide.
• Word Association for "Up high": roof, steeple, spire, mast, mountain.

Now, try to find the intersection. What kind of arrow or indicator is found on a roof or steeple? This line of thinking leads directly to a weather vane, an instrument designed to show wind direction.

Another approach is to consider the likely answer length. If you know you're looking for a four-letter word, you can test possibilities. Does STAR fit? The North Star is a "pointer up high," but the clue feels more grounded and less celestial. If you get a crossing letter, say the 'A' in the second position (A_), VANE becomes a much stronger candidate.

Background Context

The answer refers to a weather vane, one of the oldest meteorological instruments. Its purpose is to indicate the direction from which the wind is blowing. Typically mounted on the highest point of a building, it's designed with unequal surfaces on either side of a pivot, so it can freely rotate and align itself with the wind.

While many are shaped like a simple arrow, they are often decorative, taking the form of roosters (known as weathercocks), ships, or other figures. You can learn more about their history and design on the Wikipedia page for Weather vane.

Conclusion

The elegance of "Pointer up high" is its ability to create a clear mental image that is just slightly off from the correct answer. By shifting our definition of "pointer" from an action to an object's function, the puzzle resolves beautifully. It's a classic piece of crossword cluing that rewards flexible thinking.

Hints

1. Hint 1: Think of an object often found on the roof of a building, like a barn or a church.
2. Hint 2: This object serves a directional purpose.
3. Hint 3: It's related to meteorology and tells you something about the current weather conditions.
4. Hint 4: This device, often shaped like an arrow or a rooster, shows which way the wind is blowing.